On Man-eating: Does it "Fit" in Touhou?

I'm gonna be honest dude, I'm not sure where this comes from either and heard this in a youtube video. But to clarify, by "outsiders" I meant people from outside world who spawned in. And if I remembered correctly, villagers are only protected when they are within the village, but not outside of it.
Lol hey I don't blame you, a lot of what people think of Gensokyo is this mishmash of different things that has been written about it read through other people's summaries. Maybe while I keep working my way through all the official Touhou media I'll be able to source this idea myself. Even with what I've read I see things developing in that direction so it's very believable to me it is in there somewhere.



Looking back, I should've used Lucky Star as an example. It's one of the best in it's subgenre, and yet as a story, it doesn't have any narrative depth, thought-provoking messages, or anything else that snobs like. The trashy manga I mentioned wasn't really outstanding even in it's niche.
Ah ha, that's a bit of a different question. I haven't watched Lucky Star but I've seen Nichijou and I imagine it's a similar concept.

You can still do the same comparisons I made out above. I think that everything I said about comparing something to Blood Meridian would probably be true when compared to something like Lucky Star.

But that doesn't do Lucky Star justice, does it? Lucky Star is probably funnier than Blood Meridian in a more casual format. Lucky Star probably has cuter characters than Blood Meridian does.

Above I wrote that elements like the writing don't make up an equal part of the whole work across every work. Well, similarly, not every piece of writing should be judged equally across all works. Genre and intention needs to be taken into account, because one piece of writing can't do everything, right? Haven't I spent all this time making the point that Touhou is trying to do two different things and they don't work together?

So when it comes to a comparison like you are bringing up here between Lucky Star and Blood Meridian, we could try to compare them, but we don't really learn much about either work in that case because they have entirely different goals. (I assume) Lucky Star succeeds at creating casual comedy between cute and sweet characters and Blood Meridian succeeds at making one ponder fundamental questions about humanity and the motivations of people.

When comparing things that are so different, using such an unspecific word like "better" or "worse" in an unspecific category like "writing" becomes less useful. It's important that these words are used to help get a message across in a succinct way, and when they start introducing more questions than giving answers we should probably discard them.

But, obviously that doesn't make them harmful in every case. Consider Lucky Star specifically against a scale of other comedy animes and we can start using these words again because we should all have some general idea of what they would mean.

So I guess that my overall idea is that sometimes it is better to look at things on many sub-scales, rather than think of some giant overall scale that is the perfect judge of both Lucky Star and Blood Meridian, right? In this case, if someone used "good" or "bad" with Lucky Star, you can probably assume they are comparing it to other comedy animes, and if someone uses the same for Blood Meridian, you can probably assume they are comparing it to other more serious novel-type writing.
 
Yeah I do agree with most of these points in a sense, I never particularly seen the heavy "grimdark" aspects but it's also ZUN not particularly having the strongest consistency with saying certain concepts and then never particularly going as hard on them

Not that he needs to, but whenever I tend to hear these things I don't pay it too strongly in mind, bc at the end of the day alot of people do enjoy these characters either bc they vibe with their designs, lore or we just like these cute/enjoyable characters in a nutshell
And also from a story satisfaction standpoint. With just what is in EoSD, for example, I think the ending is satisfying. A vampire who the character description for describes is too weak of an eater to kill most people plagues the skies with mist so she can go out during the day, and then we stop her and befriend her. But if you add in this other information that she is commonly having people delivered to her to eat on a regular basis do we really feel like we "solved" the Remilia problem? Does it make sense that we are now friendly with her?
As for this part, I want to imagine more of a sense it could just be "shonen-esque" tropes of bonds of friendship rather than wanting a darker ending or just killing off Remilia, it's a great ending in a way

But yeah the grimdark elements do contradict the tone of what ZUN was going for, I'm not gonna act like an expert myself on how the story should've been written bc a majority of Touhou plots can be summed up in a paragraph or two

The omakes just provide a lot of the extra details and info on characters that aren't in the games, and the casual fan isn't gonna go read them unless they're that hardcore (I mean the wikis can provide stuff easier anyways) (the notes are provided in the files of the game, just not in the game)
 
Back
Top