Jump to content

Can ZUN draw a mature/adult-looking character?


CountVonNumenor

Recommended Posts

(Repost from r/touhou found here)
https://www.reddit.com/r/touhou/comments/wq9ich/can_zun_draw_a_matureadultlooking_character/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3)

 

I really do not want to insult his art style. There is something unique about it, and represents one of the defining features for the Touhou games. My question is coming from reading the notes ZUN wrote for his miscellaneous drawings, particularly the commentary for "Zun008.JPG" (dated 20/05/2001, so from the pre-EoSD era). The English translated version is from the wiki:

slaexx32x5i91.jpg?width=768&format=pjpg&

Translated Name: Blonde Shrine Maiden From a Future Era

I wanted to draw a "poster shrine maiden."
My original concept was to truly draw a sultry, adult-looking shrine maiden for once.
No, really. (^^;
But it turned out to be a young girl. (lol)
It's just that since I was drawing a poster girl, I wanted something that would grab and entice
with vivid colors and a subtle expression on the girl.
But I guess it's a pointless picture. (^^;

 

As seen, apparently ZUN wanted to represent a mature-looking character. However, it ended up looking much younger than planned. Since that is old, quite possibly outdated information, has he managed to improve on that? Can he now finally draw an adult character, or he is pretty much defined into the style that defines him and his work?

 

  • Like 1
  • Thinking 4
  • Thanks 1

spacer.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 hours ago, Darksymphony777 said:

raiko looks straight up like a young adut

If you mean about Raiko looking like a teenager, then I would say so. She does not really look like an adult. Or now we are talking about semantics, and "young adult" is a weird word I tend to associate more with those of the age of 16-18 instead of anything up to the age of 25. Anyway, neither her original art from DDC nor the illustration from Who's Who of Humans and Youkai make her look so much like an adult, at best looking like a young adult. Especially focusing on the ZUN image

Th14Raiko.png

Same rounded features and fat baby cheeks, even if not as obvious as in other images I am gonna show in a bit. Meanwhile, despite not a ZUN illustration, but still an official art (I always feel tempted to bring those in because, even if not drawn by him, are still made based on indications from ZUN if I am not wrong). She looks even more like a child in Who's Who 

Raiko_Whos_Who.png

 

spacer.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Two  more comments I took notice of from the orignal post of this question:

"Characters like Nemuno, Urumi, and Junko look older than young girls, but they still don't really look like adults to me. I think it's just his art style. He doesn't draw wrinkles or angles. Characters drawn in ZUN style are round and have smooth skin and huge eyes. Those are all features of babies."
 

"I mean look at Byakuren's sprite in UFO, she looks like a tall kid not an actual grown-ass woman. Also take a look at the ZUN's music collections covers. Specifically Changeability of Strange Dream's cover then compare it to 5.5's and Old Bar Adam. The more time passes the younger they look, and they're supposed to be university students..."

unknown.png

unknown.png

unknown.png

unknown.png

Looking at those, yeah, they really do seem to regress in age with each album (pointed out here with the extremes, first two and most recent two CD covers). Maribel and Renko really do look like toddlers on CD 9.5 if you ask me to be honest. I was supposed to get this part of text written many hours ago, but got something on the way and only now did I manage to get back home and write it. 

 

  • Like 3

spacer.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, CountVonNumenor said:

If you mean about Raiko looking like a teenager, then I would say so. She does not really look like an adult. Or now we are talking about semantics, and "young adult" is a weird word I tend to associate more with those of the age of 16-18 instead of anything up to the age of 25

Guess we have different definitions of young adult. She looks like she's in her early 20's to me

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Darksymphony777 said:

Guess we have different definitions of young adult. She looks like she's in her early 20's to me

Maybe. To me, Raiko's art (if we mean the cuts one one and not tiny battle sprite),  she really does not look like being in her 20s. Or maybe I'm stuck with the trope (which official Touhou,  as well as fanart sometimes failed to disprove) of everyone looking like being 14-16 (your average anime protagonist age). Maybe fanart did a better job with other images of her,  and it's debatable what age you'd give her based on the cameo sprite from 15.5. But ZUN art? To me,  it still fails to show that age. 

spacer.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, CountVonNumenor said:

Maybe. To me, Raiko's art (if we mean the cuts one one and not tiny battle sprite),  she really does not look like being in her 20s. Or maybe I'm stuck with the trope (which official Touhou,  as well as fanart sometimes failed to disprove) of everyone looking like being 14-16 (your average anime protagonist age). Maybe fanart did a better job with other images of her,  and it's debatable what age you'd give her based on the cameo sprite from 15.5. But ZUN art? To me,  it still fails to show that age. 

and kanako? you never really said anything about her

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

@CountVonNumenor Presumably, you have more experience with/understanding of standard artistic depiction of human features, both in general and in specific relation to age. As such, you are able to analyze Zun's artstyle against said standard and judge it accordingly. I am not so familiar with such standards, and as such I am only capable of viewing this art according to personal perception. I note a wide variety of appearances in the people I see, and as such my association between appearance and age is less defined (additionally, people here are occasionally insecure about their age, discouraging analysis). When I look at Zun's art, the most I perceive is the proportionate depiction of the human figure, and associated aesthetic considerations. I like his art style, and that's about as far as it goes.

  • Like 2

TTT

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, Darksymphony777 said:

and kanako? you never really said anything about her

Oh, sorry. Let me look a bit at her portrait from MoF:

Th10KanakoYasaka.png

I am not so sure what to say specifically about her ZUN art depiction. The only thing coming to my mind is "extremely fluffy hair". But year, she looks a bit like a tall girl. 

 

4 hours ago, Ken Hisuag said:

Presumably, you have more experience with/understanding of standard artistic depiction of human features, both in general and in specific relation to age.

Just a bit. I am not much better than you when it comes to that. Especially since I fail big time when I try to guess ages even in real life when it comes to other people. Again, I do not hate the ZUN art -  there are some illustrations of his I absolutely love. I was however wondering given the notes he gave on that illustration from 2001, especially since it does not look like he has made any similar comment ever since. 

spacer.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

actually i feel like 18.5 marisa feels like older than she was represented before, maybe not as adult but like:

100th Black Market

she has longer hair, seems a little taller to me as well

considering we've seen reimu and marisa as kids in 98 era and as teenagers (technically) in current era we might at some point eventually see them reaching adulthood as well

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 8/23/2022 at 12:32 PM, Shionne Imeris said:

actually i feel like 18.5 Marisa feels like older than she was represented before, maybe not as adult but like:

100th Black Market

she has longer hair, seems a little taller to me as well

She does look slightly longer than usual in this image. Besides, the more washed away shade of yellow on her hair is in interesting choice. However, I still cannot fully go away from the rounded, fat shapes of the head and huge bug eyes characteristic to ZUN's art. She is still slightly flat-chested, but it is still slightly more than what he used to draw in the past. 

 

On 8/23/2022 at 12:32 PM, Shionne Imeris said:

considering we've seen Reimu and Marisa as kids in 98 era and as teenagers (technically) in current era we might at some point eventually see them reaching adulthood as well

Yeah, that has to be a bigger change. They almost look like completely different characters once making the transition from PC-98 to the Windows era. As if the whole series got rebooted or something... Is that why people suppose the two of them were age 10 at the time of EoSD (or was that during the PC-98 canon era)?

  • Like 1

spacer.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

32 minutes ago, adzi said:

hmmm

can they drink sake?

In Gensokyo, it looks like almost everyone but Sumireko and perhaps a few more can drink sake. We do not know however if they respect the outside world laws when it comes to consuming tobacco and alcohol (most be at least 18 years old), or Gensokyo works on "we don't care, let the kids drink too" (not too far from how it works in Romania too - officially, you have to be 18, but at least until recently, you could often see 14 year old smoking or drinking high alcohol spirit drinks, as small shops did not really care who they sold their products to).

spacer.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 8/25/2022 at 1:09 PM, CountVonNumenor said:

Yeah, that has to be a bigger change. They almost look like completely different characters once making the transition from PC-98 to the Windows era. As if the whole series got rebooted or something... Is that why people suppose the two of them were age 10 at the time of EoSD (or was that during the PC-98 canon era)?

i feel like this, yeah although most of the 98 era canon is much less cohesive and often MUCH less detailed than any of windows era
there's a lot of fanon theories why this and why that though but barely any info about 98 era is confirmed by ZUN
although first thing is 98 games were much more brutal than windows games because spell cards rules didn't exist back then so i suppose lot of fights were to death or severe injuries
second: lot of 98 characters were specific to their game only and made appearance only once and never again (this is especially true about whole HRtP cast aside from Mima)
i heard a lot of fanon theories that after events from MS and young alice fight (essentialy last fight in the era since shes extra stage boss) she opened/used her grimoire somehow which caused some kind of catastrophe, space rift or whatever which only Alice, Marisa, Reimu and Yuuka survived (especially considering windows alice does hold a grimoire that's never supposed to be opened which iirc marisa tried to do/ask about once)

Reimu in 98 era is also smaller (i think) and so is Marisa and Yuuka also changed (hairstyle and eyes color)

also remember that HRtP bad ending was literally whole planed exploding (both endings with slight differences iirc) and one of SoEW bad endings was marisa literally crucifying reimu as part of her "training" 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Reimu in Touhou 1 doesn't looks like a kid, she seems more like a 19 year old girl...  🤣 (ZUN made her looking like a kid since Touhou 2 though...)

I think that Kongara (the black haired woman) looks kinda mature, no? Since her eyes are not taking the half of her face and that she has adult proportions

 

Reimu.PNG

hptr.PNG

Edited by Nekofire
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Nekofire said:

Reimu in Touhou 1 doesn't looks like a kid, she seems more like a 19 year old girl...  🤣 (ZUN made her looking like a kid since Touhou 2 though...) I think that Konngara (the black haired woman) looks kinda mature, no? Since her eyes are not taking the half of her face and that she has adult proportions

Yes, you have made a very good point. Most, if not all of the characters from Touhou 1 that makes them look as if they were older. Which is weird, given the sudden turn starting with Touhou 2, and then continued into the Windows era. 

Th01cover.jpg

The cover art for HRtP is a bit of an exception on that part though. But like you pointed out, the other character at for Reimu has her more aged up. 

unknown.png

First time I remarked a character looked rather mature in that game was with Sariel though. I was also impressed about the effect of her dress moving in what looked like wind, as if there were clothing physics (which for reasons disappeared with the following games) 

Edited by CountVonNumenor

spacer.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.